The Future of Revenue How Blockchain is Rewriting
Sure, here is a soft article about blockchain revenue models.
The world is on the cusp of a financial revolution, and blockchain technology is the engine driving it. While many associate blockchain solely with Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies, its potential extends far beyond digital cash. Blockchain is fundamentally changing how we conceive of value exchange, ownership, and, most importantly, revenue generation. We are witnessing the birth of entirely new economic paradigms, moving away from the centralized, often opaque models of the past towards a more distributed, transparent, and user-centric future. This shift is not a distant dream; it's happening now, and understanding these evolving blockchain revenue models is key to navigating the opportunities and challenges of this transformative era.
At its core, blockchain is a distributed, immutable ledger that records transactions across a network of computers. This inherent transparency and security have opened doors to novel ways of creating and capturing value. Traditional revenue models often rely on intermediaries, charging fees for services, or selling access to data. Blockchain, with its ability to disintermediate, automate, and democratize, is upending these established norms.
One of the most significant shifts blockchain introduces is the concept of tokenization. This is the process of representing real-world assets or utility as digital tokens on a blockchain. Think of it as dividing ownership of an asset into smaller, tradable units. This can apply to anything: real estate, art, intellectual property, company shares, or even future revenue streams. The revenue models that emerge from tokenization are diverse. Companies can sell these tokens to raise capital, effectively creating a new form of crowdfunding. Investors, in turn, can buy tokens representing ownership or access, participating in the success of the underlying asset or venture. This opens up investment opportunities to a much wider audience, breaking down geographical and financial barriers.
For example, a real estate developer could tokenize a new apartment building. Instead of seeking a large bank loan, they could sell tokens representing fractional ownership of the building. Investors worldwide could purchase these tokens, providing the necessary capital. The revenue generated from rent or sales of apartments would then be distributed proportionally to token holders, all managed automatically via smart contracts. This model not only democratizes real estate investment but also provides liquidity to an otherwise illiquid asset. Similarly, artists can tokenize their artwork, selling limited editions as NFTs (Non-Fungible Tokens), allowing fans and collectors to own a piece of digital or even physical art, with smart contracts ensuring royalties are automatically paid to the artist on every subsequent resale.
Beyond tokenization of existing assets, blockchain enables the creation of entirely new digital assets with inherent utility, leading to utility token models. These tokens are designed to provide access to a product, service, or network. Companies can issue utility tokens to fund the development of their platform or decentralized application (dApp). Users who purchase these tokens gain the right to use the service, whether it's paying for transaction fees on a blockchain network, accessing premium features in a game, or participating in the governance of a decentralized autonomous organization (DAO). The revenue for the platform comes from the initial sale of these tokens and, in some cases, from ongoing fees paid in the utility token for continued access or enhanced services. This model aligns incentives between the platform providers and their users, as the value of the token is directly tied to the adoption and success of the platform.
A prime example is a decentralized storage network. Instead of relying on centralized cloud providers, users can rent out their unused hard drive space, earning tokens for doing so. Other users can then purchase these tokens to store their data. The network operator, the entity that built and maintains the protocol, generates revenue through a small percentage of the transaction fees or by selling a portion of the initial token supply. This creates a competitive market for storage, potentially driving down costs for consumers and creating income opportunities for individuals.
Another compelling blockchain revenue model is built around Decentralized Finance (DeFi). DeFi aims to recreate traditional financial services—lending, borrowing, trading, insurance—on decentralized blockchain networks, eliminating intermediaries like banks. DeFi platforms generate revenue through various mechanisms. Lending protocols, for instance, earn a spread between the interest paid by borrowers and the interest paid to lenders. Decentralized exchanges (DEXs), which allow peer-to-peer trading of digital assets, typically generate revenue through small transaction fees, often referred to as "gas fees," which are paid to validators or miners who process the transactions. Yield farming platforms incentivize users to provide liquidity to these DEXs by offering rewards in the form of new tokens. While users earn these rewards, the platform itself might generate revenue by charging a small percentage of the farming rewards or through other service fees.
The innovation in DeFi revenue models is their ability to distribute value more broadly. Instead of a bank capturing all the profit from lending, a portion is returned to the individuals providing the capital. This has the potential to create more equitable financial systems, where users can earn passive income on their digital assets and have greater control over their finances. The complexity here lies in the intricate interplay of smart contracts, liquidity pools, and staking mechanisms, all designed to automate financial processes and reward participation.
The rise of Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) has unlocked an entirely new category of revenue models, primarily centered around digital ownership and scarcity. While NFTs are often associated with digital art, their applications are far broader. Beyond the initial sale of an NFT, revenue can be generated through royalty fees programmed into the smart contract. This means that every time an NFT is resold on a secondary marketplace, a predetermined percentage of the sale price is automatically sent back to the original creator or rights holder. This provides creators with a continuous revenue stream, a stark contrast to traditional art sales where the artist typically receives nothing from subsequent resales.
NFTs are also being used to represent ownership of virtual land in metaverses, in-game items, digital collectibles, and even tickets to events. The revenue models here can include primary sales of NFTs, secondary market royalties, and the sale of associated digital or physical goods. Companies can create exclusive NFT collections that grant holders access to special communities, events, or early access to future products. The scarcity and verifiable ownership provided by NFTs create demand and value, allowing for innovative monetization strategies that were previously unimaginable. Consider a gaming company that creates in-game assets as NFTs. Players can buy, sell, and trade these items, and the company can earn revenue from the initial sale and a small cut of every subsequent transaction on the in-game marketplace.
Furthermore, the emergence of Web3 and the concept of "play-to-earn" games represent a significant evolution in digital economies. In traditional games, players spend money to progress or acquire items, with little to no return on their investment. Play-to-earn games, powered by blockchain, allow players to earn cryptocurrency or NFTs by playing the game, completing quests, or winning battles. These earned assets have real-world value and can be traded on open markets. The revenue for the game developers can come from the initial sale of in-game NFTs, transaction fees on the in-game marketplace, or by taking a percentage of player-to-player trades. This creates a symbiotic relationship where players are incentivized to engage with the game, driving its economy and providing value to the developers. The revenue here is not just about selling a product; it's about fostering and participating in a vibrant, player-driven economy.
The key takeaway from these evolving models is a fundamental shift towards democratization and decentralization. Value is no longer concentrated in the hands of a few intermediaries. Instead, it's distributed among network participants, token holders, and creators. This opens up unprecedented opportunities for individuals and businesses alike to participate in and benefit from the digital economy.
Continuing our exploration into the dynamic world of blockchain revenue models, we delve deeper into how this transformative technology is not merely an alternative but often a superior method for generating and distributing value. The previous discussion touched upon tokenization, DeFi, NFTs, and Web3 gaming, painting a picture of a decentralized future. Now, let's expand on these and introduce other critical revenue streams, examining the underlying mechanics and their implications for businesses and individuals.
One of the most direct and powerful applications of blockchain is in creating decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs). These are organizations governed by code and community consensus, rather than a central authority. Revenue generation in DAOs is intrinsically linked to their purpose and the tokens they issue. A DAO might be formed to invest in specific projects, manage a decentralized protocol, or curate digital art. Their revenue can come from several sources. If a DAO invests in other blockchain projects, its revenue is derived from the profits of those investments. If it governs a protocol, revenue might be generated from transaction fees on that protocol, which are then used to fund the DAO's operations or distributed to token holders. Many DAOs also generate revenue through the sale of governance tokens, which grant holders voting rights and a stake in the organization's future. The beauty of this model is its transparency; all treasury activities and governance decisions are recorded on the blockchain, fostering trust and accountability among members. The revenue generated can be reinvested into the DAO, used to reward contributors, or distributed as dividends to token holders, creating a self-sustaining and community-driven economic ecosystem.
Beyond financial applications, blockchain is revolutionizing how data is monetized, ushering in data-as-a-service models that are both privacy-preserving and value-generating. In the traditional web, user data is often collected and monetized by large corporations without explicit user consent or compensation. Blockchain offers a paradigm shift. Individuals can now control their data through decentralized identity solutions and choose to sell or license access to it, directly benefiting from its value. Companies, in turn, can access high-quality, verified data directly from users, often at a lower cost and with greater certainty of compliance with privacy regulations.
Imagine a blockchain platform where users anonymously contribute their health data for medical research. Instead of pharmaceutical companies scraping data from various sources, they can pay tokens directly to individuals on the platform for anonymized datasets. The platform operator facilitates these transactions, potentially taking a small service fee. This not only creates a new revenue stream for individuals but also ensures that the data being used for research is accurate and ethically sourced. This personal data marketplaces model empowers users and builds trust, as they are active participants in the monetization of their own information.
The concept of "staking" in blockchain networks has also evolved into a significant revenue model, particularly for those who hold specific cryptocurrencies. Proof-of-Stake (PoS) consensus mechanisms, which are becoming increasingly prevalent, require network participants to "stake" their coins as collateral to validate transactions and secure the network. In return for their service and commitment, stakers are rewarded with newly minted coins or transaction fees. This effectively creates a passive income stream for coin holders, incentivizing them to hold and support the network.
Beyond direct network rewards, liquid staking protocols have emerged, allowing users to stake their assets while still retaining liquidity to use them in other DeFi applications. These protocols generate revenue by charging a small fee on the staking rewards or through their own native token utility. This model is particularly attractive as it combines the security benefits of staking with the flexibility of DeFi, appealing to a broader range of investors looking to generate yield on their crypto holdings. The revenue generated through staking is a direct reflection of the network's security and activity, making it a sustainable and scalable revenue stream for both individuals and the blockchain protocols themselves.
Furthermore, the burgeoning field of blockchain gaming and metaverses presents a rich tapestry of revenue models that go far beyond traditional in-game purchases. As mentioned earlier, "play-to-earn" is a significant component. However, revenue extends to the creation and sale of virtual land, digital real estate, and unique experiences within these virtual worlds. Developers can sell plots of land, which users can then develop to host events, build businesses, or rent out. The metaverse operator can take a cut of these land sales, property taxes, or transaction fees within the virtual economy.
Beyond land, digital assets such as avatars, skins, and special abilities can be tokenized as NFTs. Players can buy, sell, and trade these items, creating a vibrant player-driven economy. The game developers can earn revenue from the initial sale of these assets, a commission on secondary market sales, and by developing premium content or features that require specialized NFTs or in-game currency. The metaverse also opens up opportunities for advertising and sponsorships, where brands can establish virtual presences, host events, or sponsor in-game activities, paying in cryptocurrency or fiat for these services. The revenue here is generated by building and nurturing engaging virtual worlds that attract users and foster economic activity within them.
Another innovative approach is Decentralized Content Monetization. Platforms are emerging that allow creators of content—be it articles, music, videos, or code—to publish directly to the blockchain and receive payments from their audience in cryptocurrency. This often bypasses traditional content platforms that take a significant cut. Creators can receive direct tips, sell exclusive content as NFTs, or use subscription models where fans pay a recurring fee in tokens for access. The revenue for the platform itself can come from a small transaction fee on these payments, or by offering premium tools and analytics to creators. This model empowers creators by giving them more control over their intellectual property and a larger share of the revenue generated from their work. The transparency of blockchain ensures that payments are processed securely and efficiently, fostering a more direct relationship between creator and consumer.
Finally, blockchain-based enterprise solutions are creating significant revenue streams for companies developing and implementing these technologies. While much of the public focus is on cryptocurrencies, many businesses are leveraging blockchain for supply chain management, identity verification, secure record-keeping, and cross-border payments. The revenue models here are typically B2B (business-to-business) and can include:
Software-as-a-Service (SaaS): Offering blockchain platforms or tools on a subscription basis for businesses to integrate into their operations. Consulting and Implementation Services: Helping traditional companies understand and adopt blockchain technology, including custom development and integration. Transaction Fees: For permissioned blockchains, a network operator might charge fees for transaction processing or data storage. Licensing: Licensing blockchain protocols or intellectual property to other companies.
These enterprise solutions are often built on private or permissioned blockchains, offering greater control and scalability for specific business needs. The revenue generated from these models is substantial, as businesses recognize the efficiency, security, and transparency that blockchain can bring to their operations. The development of robust and user-friendly enterprise-grade blockchain solutions is a significant growth area, driving innovation and creating substantial economic value.
In conclusion, blockchain revenue models represent a profound shift in how value is created, captured, and distributed. From democratizing investment through tokenization and DeFi, to empowering creators with NFTs and decentralized content platforms, to enabling new economic paradigms in gaming and enterprise solutions, blockchain is fundamentally rewriting the rules of revenue. As the technology matures and adoption grows, we can expect to see even more innovative models emerge, fostering a more open, equitable, and value-driven digital economy. The future of revenue is here, and it's built on blockchain.
The allure of blockchain technology and its accompanying digital assets has captivated the global financial consciousness. What began as a niche fascination for tech enthusiasts and cypherpunks has rapidly evolved into a mainstream phenomenon, attracting significant capital and sparking fervent debate. For the aspiring blockchain investor, navigating this dynamic terrain requires more than just a cursory understanding of Bitcoin or Ethereum; it demands a fundamental shift in perspective, a cultivated "Blockchain Investment Mindset." This isn't merely about chasing the latest hype or predicting the next moonshot. Instead, it’s about cultivating a deep-seated understanding of the underlying technology, its potential applications, and the inherent volatility that defines this nascent asset class.
At its heart, the blockchain investment mindset is characterized by a blend of visionary optimism and pragmatic realism. It acknowledges the disruptive power of decentralized ledger technology – its ability to foster transparency, security, and efficiency across a myriad of industries, from finance and supply chain management to healthcare and digital identity. This vision is coupled with a sober appreciation for the significant risks involved. Blockchain is still in its evolutionary stages. Regulatory frameworks are fragmented and evolving, technological advancements are rapid and often unpredictable, and market sentiment can swing wildly based on news, tweets, and macroeconomic shifts. Therefore, a successful investor must be able to hold both the grand vision of a decentralized future and the granular understanding of present-day challenges.
One of the cornerstones of this mindset is a commitment to continuous learning. The blockchain space is not static; it's a constantly evolving ecosystem of new protocols, innovative applications, and shifting economic models. An investor who believes they can "set it and forget it" in this market is likely to be disappointed. This necessitates a proactive approach to education. It means delving into the whitepapers of projects, understanding the consensus mechanisms, exploring the tokenomics (the economic design of a cryptocurrency), and keeping abreast of regulatory developments in different jurisdictions. It involves understanding the difference between a utility token, a security token, and a governance token, and recognizing that each has different implications for investment and risk. Furthermore, comprehending the broader landscape of decentralized finance (DeFi), non-fungible tokens (NFTs), and decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs) provides a more holistic view of the innovation unfolding. This continuous learning isn't about becoming a developer, but about developing a sophisticated comprehension of the technological and economic underpinnings that drive value.
Resilience is another critical trait. The cryptocurrency markets are notorious for their volatility. Price swings of 20%, 50%, or even more within a short period are not uncommon. An investor with a weak constitution can easily succumb to panic selling during downturns or FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out) buying during irrational exuberance. The blockchain investment mindset embraces this volatility not as a bug, but as a feature of a developing market. It encourages investors to develop a strong emotional discipline, to avoid impulsive decisions driven by fear or greed. This often translates into adopting a long-term perspective. Instead of focusing on day-to-day price fluctuations, a resilient investor looks at the fundamental value proposition of a project and its potential to achieve its long-term goals. This perspective allows them to weather market storms, viewing dips as potential accumulation opportunities rather than existential threats.
Diversification, though a classic investment principle, takes on a unique dimension in the blockchain space. While spreading capital across different traditional asset classes like stocks and bonds is standard practice, diversifying within the blockchain ecosystem itself is equally important. This means not putting all your eggs into Bitcoin or Ethereum. It involves exploring different sectors within blockchain, such as infrastructure projects, DeFi protocols, metaverse platforms, or specialized layer-2 scaling solutions. Each of these sectors carries its own set of risks and potential rewards. Moreover, diversification extends to the type of digital assets one holds. Some investors might favor established, large-cap cryptocurrencies with proven track records, while others might allocate a smaller portion of their portfolio to promising, but higher-risk, early-stage projects. The key is to create a portfolio that balances risk and reward, and that reflects a comprehensive understanding of the various niches within the blockchain universe.
A disciplined approach to risk management is paramount. This begins with investing only what one can afford to lose. The speculative nature of many digital assets means that capital can be lost entirely. Beyond this fundamental rule, it involves defining clear investment objectives and risk tolerance. Are you seeking aggressive growth, or are you more risk-averse? This will dictate the types of projects you consider and the allocation within your portfolio. Setting stop-loss orders, carefully managing leverage if used (which is generally discouraged for most retail investors in this volatile space), and conducting thorough due diligence on every project are all essential components of a robust risk management strategy. Due diligence in blockchain goes beyond traditional financial analysis; it includes evaluating the technical viability of the project, the expertise and transparency of the development team, the community engagement and support, and the clarity of the project's roadmap. A project with a brilliant idea but a weak team or a lack of clear development milestones is a red flag that a seasoned investor will recognize.
Understanding the evolving regulatory landscape is not just a matter of compliance; it's a strategic imperative. Governments worldwide are grappling with how to regulate cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology. These regulations can significantly impact the value and accessibility of certain digital assets. A blockchain investor needs to be aware of the regulatory environment in their own jurisdiction and in the jurisdictions where the projects they invest in are based or operate. This awareness allows for proactive adjustments to investment strategies, helping to mitigate potential risks associated with regulatory crackdowns or changes in policy. It also means being able to identify projects that are proactively working towards regulatory compliance or that operate in areas less likely to face immediate stringent regulation.
Finally, the blockchain investment mindset embraces the spirit of decentralization. This means being open to new forms of governance and ownership, such as those facilitated by DAOs. It involves understanding that value creation in the blockchain space is often community-driven and that participation in these ecosystems can sometimes be as rewarding as direct financial investment. It’s about recognizing that this technology is fundamentally about shifting power away from centralized intermediaries and towards individuals and communities. This philosophical alignment with decentralization can lead to a deeper appreciation for the long-term potential of these networks and the projects building upon them, fostering a more patient and conviction-driven investment approach.
In essence, the blockchain investment mindset is a holistic approach that combines technological curiosity, financial prudence, emotional fortitude, and a forward-looking perspective. It’s a continuous journey of learning, adaptation, and disciplined execution in a landscape that promises both unprecedented innovation and significant challenges.
Building upon the foundational principles of the blockchain investment mindset, the next layer of understanding involves delving into practical strategies and the nuanced realities of navigating this rapidly evolving financial frontier. It's one thing to conceptualize vision and resilience; it's quite another to translate these attributes into actionable investment decisions within the often chaotic digital asset markets. This requires a keen eye for innovation, a rigorous approach to valuation (however nascent), and an unwavering commitment to personal financial prudence.
The search for genuine innovation is at the core of discerning valuable blockchain projects. The blockchain space is awash with a multitude of cryptocurrencies and decentralized applications (dApps), each vying for attention and capital. A discerning investor with a blockchain mindset actively seeks projects that solve real-world problems or create novel use cases that traditional systems cannot efficiently address. This means moving beyond the superficial allure of a flashy website or an aggressive marketing campaign and instead scrutinizing the underlying technology, the problem it aims to solve, and the competitive landscape. Is the project building a truly decentralized exchange that offers superior liquidity and lower fees? Is it developing a secure and scalable solution for digital identity verification? Is it creating new economic models for content creators or gamers through NFTs and play-to-earn mechanics? Identifying these genuine innovations requires a deep dive into the technical architecture, the potential network effects, and the long-term sustainability of the business model. It's about finding projects that have a clear value proposition and a defensible moat, whether that's through superior technology, a strong community, or unique network effects.
Valuation in the blockchain space is a frontier all its own. Traditional valuation metrics like Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratios or Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) models are often ill-suited to the early-stage, often unprofitable nature of many crypto projects. This necessitates the development of a more bespoke approach. Investors must consider metrics like Total Value Locked (TVL) for DeFi protocols, network transaction volume, user adoption rates, developer activity, and token velocity. Understanding the tokenomics is crucial here. What is the inflation rate of the token? What is the distribution mechanism? Are there incentives for long-term holding and participation? A well-designed tokenomic model can create intrinsic value and drive demand, even in the absence of traditional revenue streams. The blockchain investor learns to assess these non-traditional metrics, understanding that value creation can manifest in many forms, from network security and utility to governance rights and access to decentralized services. It’s an exercise in creative accounting and forward-looking projections, always tempered with a healthy dose of skepticism.
The imperative to conduct thorough due diligence cannot be overstated. This extends beyond merely reading the whitepaper. It involves investigating the development team – their background, track record, and transparency. Are they publicly known, or are they operating anonymously? While anonymity isn't inherently bad, it adds a layer of risk. It involves assessing the project's community engagement on platforms like Discord, Telegram, and Twitter. A vibrant, engaged, and constructive community can be a powerful indicator of a project's long-term potential, while a toxic or apathetic community can be a major red flag. Security audits are also critical. Has the project's smart contracts been audited by reputable third-party security firms? Vulnerabilities in smart contracts have led to significant losses in the past. Furthermore, understanding the competitive landscape is vital. How does this project stack up against existing solutions or other emerging projects? A competitive analysis helps to gauge the project's market potential and its ability to capture market share. This meticulous due diligence is the investor's shield against scams, poorly conceived projects, and ultimately, substantial financial losses.
Strategic capital allocation is another hallmark of a sophisticated blockchain investment mindset. This involves deciding not just how much to invest, but how to allocate that capital across different types of blockchain assets and at different stages of project development. For instance, a portion might be allocated to established, blue-chip cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum, which are seen as relatively safer, albeit with slower growth potential. Another portion might be dedicated to promising layer-1 or layer-2 scaling solutions that aim to improve the efficiency and reduce the cost of blockchain transactions. A smaller, more speculative allocation might be reserved for early-stage projects with disruptive potential, understanding that the risk of failure is significantly higher. This strategic allocation should align with the investor's overall risk tolerance and financial goals, ensuring that the pursuit of high returns doesn't jeopardize their financial stability. It's about building a diversified portfolio within the digital asset space, much like one would diversify across different sectors in traditional markets.
Cultivating patience and a long-term perspective is not just about enduring volatility; it's about allowing innovation to mature. Blockchain technology is still in its relative infancy. Many of the applications and protocols that will define the future are still being built, tested, and refined. Projects that show promise today may take years to reach their full potential, and their initial valuations may not reflect their eventual impact. Investors with a blockchain mindset understand that significant technological shifts don't happen overnight. They are willing to hold their investments through development cycles, market corrections, and periods of uncertainty, believing in the fundamental thesis of the project and the broader adoption of blockchain technology. This long-term view helps to mitigate the emotional toll of short-term market fluctuations and allows for the compounding of returns over time.
A commitment to personal security is paramount in the digital asset space. This involves understanding and implementing best practices for securing digital assets, such as using hardware wallets, strong passwords, and two-factor authentication. It also means being aware of common phishing scams and social engineering tactics that target crypto investors. A robust personal security posture is not an optional add-on; it is an integral part of the blockchain investment mindset. The decentralized nature of these assets means that the individual bears a significant responsibility for their own security. The loss of private keys or the compromise of a digital wallet can result in the irreversible loss of funds, a harsh lesson that underscores the importance of vigilance.
Furthermore, the blockchain investor must be adaptable and willing to pivot. The technological landscape is so dynamic that strategies that worked yesterday may not work tomorrow. New protocols emerge, existing ones evolve, and regulatory environments shift. A successful investor remains flexible, constantly re-evaluating their portfolio, their investment thesis, and their strategies in light of new information and market developments. This adaptability allows them to capitalize on emerging trends and to mitigate emerging risks. It means being open to learning from mistakes, both personal and those observed in the broader market, and using those lessons to refine their approach.
Finally, understanding the broader macroeconomic context in which blockchain assets exist is increasingly important. While often viewed as an uncorrelated asset class, digital assets are not entirely immune to global economic forces. Inflationary pressures, interest rate changes, geopolitical events, and shifts in investor sentiment towards risk assets can all influence the price of cryptocurrencies. A sophisticated blockchain investor considers these macro factors, understanding how they might impact their portfolio and adjusting their strategies accordingly. This holistic view, integrating technological understanding with economic awareness, is what distinguishes a truly insightful blockchain investor.
In conclusion, the blockchain investment mindset is an evolving paradigm. It's a journey that demands intellectual curiosity, a robust understanding of technology and economics, a disciplined approach to risk, and an unshakeable emotional resilience. It is about embracing the transformative potential of decentralization while meticulously navigating the inherent complexities and volatilities of this groundbreaking new frontier. For those who cultivate this mindset, the future of finance may not only be understood but actively shaped and capitalized upon.